home

**Who Killed Mr. Hollybrass? Give two reasons to support your answer. Include your name at the end of your entry.**

**I think that Captain Jaggery killed Mr. Hollybrass because when Charlotte tried to give him the dirk, he told her to keep it under her mattress. To me that seems suspicious because when Jaggery "killed" Zachariah, Charlotte whipped Jaggery and after that, whenever she saw him, he had the look of hatred in his eyes. He wanted to get revenge on her.**

**Caroline**

** I think Captain Jaggery killed Mr. Hollybrass because he and Zachariah were the only people who knew where Charlotte had hid the dirk. Under her mattress. But, Dillingham had seen her holding it. He could have went into her old cabin and searched around the room. He could have killed Mr. Hollybrass. It wouldn't have been Charlotte because it happened when she went up to cut the sails during the storm. **

**Vincy :P **

**I think it was Captain Jaggery who killed Mr.Hollybrass because Captain Jaggery and Zacharia were the only ones who knew where the dirk was. Charlotte could not have killed him because she was cutting the sails loose and she left the dirk in her old cabin. I think that Captain Jaggery went back to Charlotte's old cabin, grabbed her dirk, came back, and killed Mr.Hollybrass. I think Jaggery ****used Charlotte's dirk so that everyone would believe it was her. **

**-Alexis :D **
 * I think that Captain Jaggery killed Mr Hollybrass because he could have done it for Charlotte's whip across his face. It is also possible that Captain Jaggery went to Charlotte's cabin to find the drk, already knowing where it was, and came out in the storm and handed Charlotte the dirk. When the dirk fell, Captain Jaggery could have picked it up and stabbed it in Mr. Hollybrass. **
 * Evonne (>.<) **

I think captin Jaggery killed Mr. Hollybrass because he was one of the people who knew where the dirk was. Charlotte was a 13 year old girl who was acused of murder. I think that sounds weird. Captin Jaggery was trying to get revenge on Charlotte because he was whipped across the face by Charlotte. What will happen next? -McKenzie😏

I think Zachariah killed Mr. Hollybrass because he knew where the dirk was and he was on deck during the storm to help Charlotte so he could have also killed Mr.Hollybrass, but it could have been anybody. Derek = **I think Captain Jaggery killed Mr. Hollybrass because he knew where Charolotte put the dirk that Zachariah had given her and said that Charolotte had killed Mr. Hollybrass. Captain Jaggery probably wanted to kill Charolotte because she whiped him. ** = = **-Anisha :D ** = =I think that Captin Jaggery killed Mr.Hollybrass because first he knew where the dirk was which was under her matress and the Captin Jaggery and Mr.Hollybrass were getting in a fight about him drivng the ship into the storm (chapter 17.) Captin Jaggery could've still been very mad and decided to stab Mr.Hollybrass and then blame someone that //he// knows wouldn't do that. Plus Charolotte was aloft when this happened. Kellum :D=

== I think Captain Jaggery killed Mr. Hollybrass. He wanted to blame Charlotte for the murder because he had a large grudge against Charlotte for her whipping him across his face and her lying to him about who gave her the dirk. I think that Captain Jaggery thought if Charlotte was accused of the murder, he would have an excuse to hang Charlotte. ==

Christian
I think Captain Jaggery killed Mr.Hollybrass because he is the one who knows that Charlotte have a dirk and she kept it under her mattress when she was living in the tiny cabin. Also maybe Captain Jaggery wanted revenge on Charlotte who whipping him in front of the crew.( I don't know why he doesn't understand it is an accident.) Linda :) Looking forward to the next chapter! (o>_<o)

=**I think that Zachariah killed Mr Hollybrass. Zachariah came out during the storm and killed him because Mr Hollybrass was the new crew member and had sided with Captain Jaggery, by not signing the red robin. Without Mr Hollybrass the captain had no crew member supporting him, he would be the only crew member that would report Zachariah if he saw him. Finally, Mr Hollybrass was also the person that whipped Zachariah.**= =**Bryce**=

**I think that Zachariah killed Mr. Hollybrass because during the storm no one could see anything almost and maybe be Zachariah took Mr. Hollybrass when no one was looking and just killed him and the next morning his intention was to kill him and for someone to find him the next morning. Maybe Zachariah wanted to get revenge on Mr. Hollybrass for hurting him .**

**Lindsey**